
SPOILERS!!!
Okay so, who saw the premiere of this last night? I never realy thought I was a big Stargate fan but, I guess I have seen all the episodes heh.. so my thoughts:
Generally, it was okay. Not stellar. Not terrible. Yes, they tried to make it more Battlestar Galactica-ish. But actually not as much as the commercials make you think, and I think most of that dark stuff is only in this first episode. Looks like the show will be pretty standard Stargate stuff from here on. Though the camera work needs to improve… hold still dangit!!
Other thoughts
-After just saying the show is not too BSG-ish, I do have to say main character Dr. Rush is so far just a slightly less evil Gaius Baltar, he looks like him, he sounds like him, and he does selfish Baltar things. Actually I think that’s why everyone is so suspicious of him…maybe they’re all BSG fans.
-There is a HUGE plot hole in the first episode. Basically they need to close off a door on their space ship, or else they will lose all their air and die. Problem - the button is on the other side of the door, so whoever pushes it will die on the other side. So the Senator heroically gives his life to do this. Why is this a problem? Because they set up earlier in the episode the fact that they happen to have a massive supply of baseball-sized remote-control flying camera-balls on board! Could THAT not push the button? HELLO!? It wasn’t even that urgent a problem, they had hours to at least try it out!
-The one actor I recognize from another show (Christopher McDonald as the Senator, from Star Trek TNG episode Yesterday’s Enterprise) gets killed, boo!
-Sex scene for no reason. it was useless, added nothing, you don’t need to waste time with this crap in Stargate (we don’t need in in Star Trek either, but that’s another discussion)
- Also overall, I felt there was about 1 hour of material stretch out across two hour here. easily could have gotten all this done in hour one, and spent hour two actually doing some Stargateting.
So, even after all that, the experience was not terrible enough to stop watching YET. As long as they fun it up some in coming episodes, and people stop fighting all the time for no reason, it could turn out okay. And there seems to be more Richard Dean Anderson next ep. So yay!